2013 NBA Draft: Cleveland Cavaliers Could Help Kyrie Irving and Dion Waiters by Selecting Ben McLemore

Updated: June 17, 2013

By Bob Evans
Senior Writer

There is a common misconception floating around that if the Cleveland Cavaliers select Ben McLemore No. 1 overall in the 2013 NBA Draft it means the Dion Waiters era in Cleveland is over before it had a chance to start. In reality, if the Cavaliers decide to select the dynamic scorer out of Kansas over Kentucky big man Nerlens Noel, it means they are adding another weapon to an already potent back court that could use some help.

I know what many of you are thinking. Why would a duo that featured an NBA All-Star in year two in Kyrie Irving and a First Team All-Rookie selection in Waiters need any help?

For starters, the duo missed a combined 44 games last season due to injury. While Irving has been every bit the superstar caliber player the Cavaliers needed to land with the No. 1 overall pick in 2011, the youngster missed 15 games in his lockout shortened rookie season and another 23 games in year two.

Irving’s aggressiveness while attacking the hole is part of the reason he is so good, but it will also lead to hard fouls and spills on the ground that his 6’3” and 191-pound frame isn’t going to be able to take from time to time. The same can be said for Waiters, who utilizes his own 6’4” and 215-pound frame to draw contact while getting to the basket. This is not to say these two players are injury prone by any means, but what it is saying is the Cavaliers need another scoring option.

This is where McLemore fits in.

The Cavaliers have 96 minutes of play time to divide between the point guard and shooting guard positions. Irving averaged 34.7 per game last year and Waiters averaged 28.8, which means the team gave 32.5 minutes to reserves that had nowhere near the scoring ability of a guy like McLemore. While the likes of C.J. Miles, Wayne Ellington, Shaun Livingston and Daniel Gibson filled in admirably, not one of those players has the ability to be a 20-point per game scorer—McLemore can.

Standing 6’5” and 190 pounds, McLemore has already drawn comparisons to NBA great three-point shooter Ray Allen thanks to his sweet stroke. Averaging 15.9 points, 5.2 rebounds and two assists per game in his lone season in college, McLemore showed scouts he can not only hit the outside jumper, but he has an uncanny ability to read defenses for backdoor cuts and easy opportunities around the basket. Try to think of the last Cleveland Cavaliers player who could do that—you’ll find him currently residing in South Beach.

Having a player with McLemore’s offensive abilities to share those 96 minutes per game will not only provide the Cavaliers with more scoring—they ranked No. 18 in the league at 96.5 points per game last season—but it will also force defenders to choose between doubling Irving and leaving him open, or giving Irving more isolation plays. For those of you who have enjoyed watching Irving during his first two seasons with the Cavaliers, he is at his best when able to isolate against the opposing defender thanks to his quick first step and court vision.

Another reason drafting McLemore over Noel makes sense is the current composure of the Cavaliers’ roster. While it would be great to add a potentially elite rim protector like Noel, the team does have Anderson Varejao (if healthy), 2012 first-round pick Tyler Zeller and 2011 No. 4 overall pick Tristan Thompson down low. While not elite by any means, Zeller and Thompson averaged just shy of a block per game last season.

On the other hand, the Cavaliers’ next highest wing scorers were backups C.J. Miles at 11.7 points per game and Wayne Ellington at 10.4 points per game. The Cavaliers’ own a team option on Miles for this coming season and Ellington is a restricted free agent. So not only could the Cavaliers vastly improve their scoring on the wing, but they could save some money by letting one of those two players walk in free agency and allocate it to bringing in a free agent that could help protect the rim. With all due respect to Noel, it is much easier to find a big man to defend around the rim than a guy who can put the ball in the basket like McLemore.

McLemore is not without questions of his own, as a number of scouts feel he needs to work on his ball-handling and shot creation while in isolation situations. He also had a sub-par end to his freshman season in college, putting up just 11 points against Western Kentucky and two points against North Carolina in the first two rounds of the NCAA Tournament. He did bounce back to score 20 in Kansas’ loss to Michigan in the Sweet 16, but by then the judgments had already been made.

Many people feel this conversation would not even be relevant if Noel hadn’t torn his ACL, but in this writer’s eyes the No. 1 overall pick in the NBA Draft has to have star potential, the ability to score at an elite level and be someone that can impact your team for a very long time. While Noel will certainly be a very good to great defender, his ceiling as an offensive product leaves much to be desired.

This is where McLemore wins the No. 1 overall pick, because he does have that next level ceiling for the Cavaliers’ franchise. He has the ability to come in and make a major impact from Day 1 thanks to his great shooting ability, and will also keep Irving and Waiters from having to play 40 minutes per game. McLemore also gives the team a clear-cut third (likely second) scoring option they have desperately needed.

It will be a tough sell at first, drafting the first shooting guard in 40 years at No. 1 just one year after taking Waiters at No. 4. But this isn’t a replacement selection, this is adding a dynamic playmaker to an offense currently lacking one with his abilities. It is about taking the best player available, but also the one that can change the offensive dynamic for the franchise in year one. And that player is Ben McLemore.

Follow Buckeye State Sports on Twitter @BuckeyeStSports
Follow Bob Evans on Twitter @TheRealBobEvans
“Like” Buckeye State Sports on Facebook!

Related Stories on Buckeye State Sports:

2013 NBA Draft: Cleveland Cavaliers Could Trade With These Teams in the Lottery

2013 NBA Draft: Breaking Down the Cleveland Cavaliers Potential Picks at No. 19

2013 NBA Draft: Cleveland Cavaliers Must Look at These Small Forwards Come Draft Day

Share Button
The following two tabs change content below.


  1. Scott

    June 23, 2013 at 5:55 pm

    It is tempting to go after BM, Porter, or Oladipo, but Noel is the best choice for the Cavs because all-star caliber big men are harder to find, plus the Cavs have a need for a shot blocker. He has a great work ethic, great athlete, already an elite shot blocker, and he will add weight. The Cavs can then trade for or sign a SF. They should trade #19 to DAL for Shawn Marion and #13, then at 13 they can try to land a guy like Shabazz or Jamaal Franklin, or maybe Sergey Karasev. The Cavs can find a floor spacing shooter w/ their other 1st rd pick.

  2. Roscoe

    June 17, 2013 at 11:38 pm

    They should pick McLemore because he is a major threat from deep which gives the opposing team more to worry about and Kyrie more room to drive to the hole. So if they pick them I say trade waiters and get a good asset for the team since they need a sf so ill go after Harrison Barnes if they decline ill go for Andre Iguodala out of FA to play sf if he declines keep waiters and wait till Lebron comes back to the Cavs in the 2014 off season.

  3. Calvin H

    June 17, 2013 at 5:25 pm

    Ben might help on the offense but the more pressing need is someone to help him when other SG’s blow by him the correct choice would be Noel since he can protect the basket when the tony Parker’s get loose for easy layup by smacking it back in their faces Ben is not a great defender by no stretch and the Cav’s help defenders are weak at least Noel could strengthen our defense up the middle who else can do that in the top 20 draft picks this year. They better get him while he right there in there face or waste this years pick on something they already have what good is two Waiters at the expense of defensive stopper who will score while Kyrie sets him up like Andy does and will prolong Andy’s career or get him traded

Join the Conversation